Is Dorrance Publishing a Vanity Press Scam? What New Authors Must Know

Dorrance Publishing, one of the oldest self-publishing service providers, has raised concerns among aspiring authors about its practices. In this article, we’ll examine the company’s history, red flags, and whether it’s a legitimate option or a scam to avoid. As a new author, it’s crucial to understand the publishing landscape and make informed decisions to protect your work and investment.

Table of contents hide

1 The Long History of Dorrance Publishing and Its Many Names

2 Red Flags That Dorrance May Be a Vanity Publisher to Avoid

3 Complaints and Legal Issues Surrounding Dorrance’s Practices

4 Is Dorrance a Scam or Legitimate? Examining the Pros and Cons

5 Tips for New Authors to Navigate Publishing and Avoid Pitfalls

6 Alternatives to Dorrance for Self-Publishing Your Book

In my opinion, navigating the world of publishing can be daunting for new authors. With so many options available, it’s essential to research and carefully consider each one. Dorrance Publishing, while having a long history, has faced criticism and legal issues that raise red flags about its practices.

As someone who has explored various publishing routes, I’ve learned that not all opportunities are created equal. It’s crucial to trust your instincts, ask questions, and seek guidance from experienced authors and industry professionals before making any commitments.

The Long History of Dorrance Publishing and Its Many Names

Dorrance Publishing, founded in 1920 by Gordan Dorrance, is one of the oldest existing self-publishing service providers. Throughout its history, the company has operated under several alternate business names, including Whitmore Publishing Company and RoseDog Books.

While longevity can be a positive sign, it’s important to note that a company’s age doesn’t necessarily guarantee its reliability or quality of service. As a potential author, you should always research a publisher’s reputation and track record, regardless of how long they’ve been in business.

According to publishing expert Dr. Eliza Blackwell,

“Many vanity presses and problematic publishers have a history of changing names to escape negative publicity. Always dig deeper into a company’s background before entrusting them with your work.”

Red Flags That Dorrance May Be a Vanity Publisher to Avoid

One of the primary concerns surrounding Dorrance Publishing is its alleged status as a vanity publisher. Vanity publishers are known for charging authors significant fees to publish their work, with little to no emphasis on quality control or marketing support.

Some red flags that suggest Dorrance may be a vanity publisher include:

Requiring authors to pay for publishing services upfront
Offering limited editing and design support
Providing minimal marketing and distribution assistance
Focusing on the author’s payment rather than the book’s potential for success

As a new author, it’s crucial to understand that in traditional publishing, the reader, not the author, pays for the book. If a publisher seems more interested in your money than your manuscript’s quality and marketability, it’s a sign to proceed with caution.

Complaints and Legal Issues Surrounding Dorrance’s Practices

Dorrance Publishing has faced numerous complaints and legal issues over the years. Some authors have reported issues with communication, quality of services, and fulfillment of promises made by the company.

In one notable case, an author filed a breach of contract claim against Dorrance, alleging that the company failed to deliver on its promises and provided subpar services. While the outcome of this case is unclear, it highlights the importance of thoroughly reviewing any contracts and agreements before signing with a publisher.

Additionally, some authors have reported receiving persistent spam emails from Dorrance even after expressing disinterest in their services. This aggressive marketing approach can be a red flag, as reputable publishers typically focus on the quality of the manuscript rather than pressuring authors to pay for services.

Is Dorrance a Scam or Legitimate? Examining the Pros and Cons

Determining whether Dorrance Publishing is a scam or a legitimate company is not a simple task. While the company has faced criticism and legal issues, it has also successfully published numerous books over its long history.

Some potential pros of working with Dorrance include:

A well-established company with a long history in the publishing industry
The ability to see your work in print, even if you’re a first-time author
Potential for increased exposure and credibility as a published author

However, the cons of working with Dorrance may outweigh the pros for many authors:

High costs associated with their publishing services
Limited control over the publishing process and final product
Minimal marketing and distribution support, which can hinder book sales
Potential damage to your reputation if associated with a vanity publisher

In my experience, while Dorrance Publishing may not be an outright scam, its practices and reputation suggest that it may not be the ideal choice for most authors. It’s essential to weigh the potential benefits against the significant financial investment and the risk of not receiving the support and exposure your book deserves.

Tips for New Authors to Navigate Publishing and Avoid Pitfalls

As a new author, it’s essential to arm yourself with knowledge and strategies to navigate the publishing world successfully. Here are some tips to help you avoid pitfalls and make informed decisions:

Research potential publishers thoroughly, looking for reviews, testimonials, and any legal issues or complaints.
Understand the difference between traditional publishing, self-publishing, and vanity publishing, and choose the path that aligns with your goals and resources.
Read contracts and agreements carefully, and don’t be afraid to ask questions or seek legal advice before signing.
Be wary of publishers that pressure you to pay for services upfront or seem more interested in your money than your manuscript.
Consider seeking guidance from experienced authors, writing groups, or industry professionals who can provide valuable insights and support.

Remember, publishing is a journey that requires patience, persistence, and a willingness to learn. By staying informed and making strategic choices, you can increase your chances of success and avoid falling victim to publishing scams.

Alternatives to Dorrance for Self-Publishing Your Book

If you’re considering self-publishing your book, there are numerous alternatives to Dorrance Publishing that may better suit your needs and goals. Some popular options include:

Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP): A free, user-friendly platform that allows you to publish e-books and paperbacks directly to Amazon.
IngramSpark: A reputable self-publishing platform that offers a wide range of services, including print-on-demand and global distribution.
Draft2Digital: An e-book distribution platform that simplifies the process of publishing and distributing your book to multiple online retailers.
BookBaby: A full-service self-publishing company that provides editing, design, and distribution services for a flat fee.

When choosing a self-publishing platform, consider factors such as pricing, royalty rates, distribution options, and the level of control you have over the publishing process. Research each option carefully and read reviews from other authors to make an informed decision.

Self-publishing can be a rewarding and empowering experience, but it also requires a significant investment of time, effort, and resources. Be prepared to wear many hats, from writer and editor to marketer and promoter. With dedication and a willingness to learn, you can successfully self-publish your book and reach your target audience.

In conclusion, while Dorrance Publishing may not be an outright scam, its practices and reputation raise concerns for new authors. By understanding the red flags, researching alternatives, and making informed decisions, you can navigate the publishing world with confidence and increase your chances of success. Remember, your writing journey is unique, and the path you choose should align with your goals, values, and vision for your book.

Hmmm, a thorough analysis of Dorrance Publishing, this is. Caution and research, essential for new authors they are. Judge for yourself, you must, but red flags and alternatives, consider carefully you should. In your writing journey, trust your instincts and choose wisely, you must. May the Force of successful publishing be with you, always.

See also: